Chicago drivers often wonder what color car gets pulled over the most, and the answer might surprise you. Despite the popular myth about red cars, white vehicles get pulled over the most on the road. This isn’t because Chicago police favor white cars – it’s simply because white is the most common car color out there, so there are more of them to stop. In truth, safe driving habits matter far more than paint color when avoiding tickets. Keep reading to see how color myths stack up against reality, how it all ties into local insurance facts, and what catches an officer’s attention in Illinois. For any insurance help or questions, remember: Call Insure on the Spot in Chicago at 773-202-5060 for guidance or a fast quote on coverage.
1. White Cars Are Pulled Over the Most (Because They’re Common)
It’s natural to think a flashy color might attract police, but data tells a different story. White cars get pulled over more often than any other color. Why? Simply because there are more white cars on Chicago and Illinois roads than any other color. For nearly a decade, white has been the most popular car color in the U.S., and Illinois drivers follow that trend. From city fleets to personal vehicles, white is everywhere. The result: with so many white cars, they also end up leading in traffic stops and tickets purely by volume.
To put it in perspective, here are the top car colors often associated with the highest number of traffic stops:
- White: #1 in traffic stops (most common color on the road).
- Red: #2 in stops (a popular myth, but also a fairly common color).
- Gray: #3 in stops (another very common vehicle color).
- Silver: #4 in stops (close in popularity to gray).
What about black cars? Black is also one of the most popular colors in Chicago, especially for luxury vehicles and livery cars. While black wasn’t in the very top stop list in some studies, it remains common, and common colors naturally appear more in ticket statistics. The key point is that these rankings mirror how many cars of each color are on the road, not any special targeting by law enforcement.
2. The Myth of Red Cars Getting More Tickets
Everyone has heard the old tale: “red cars get pulled over for speeding more than any other.” In Chicago, you’ll see plenty of bright red sports cars zipping down Lake Shore Drive, feeding the myth that cops have them in their sights. The reality is that red cars are not specifically targeted by Chicago police or Illinois state troopers. Red does come in second place for the number of pull-overs, but that’s largely because red is a relatively popular color (and often chosen for sports models). The myth likely persists because red is eye-catching – people notice a red car getting a ticket and remember it. Psychologically, a red car stands out in traffic, so we assume it’s ticketed more, but statistically, it’s simply behind white.
Why else do people believe the red-car myth? One reason is the association of red with speed – many high-performance cars and hot rods are painted red, creating a bias. Another reason is storytelling: a friend or family member with a red vehicle might blame their paint job for a speeding ticket. In truth, if that same person drove a white or blue car the same way, they’d likely have been pulled over just the same. Chicago police officers are looking at your speed and behavior, not your color. So, while a shiny red Mustang might turn heads, it’s the driver’s actions that will catch a cop’s attention, not the color itself.
3. Other Car Colors: Gray, Silver, and Beyond
Aside from white and red, gray and silver cars round out the top of the list for traffic stops. This makes sense because gray and silver are also extremely popular colors for vehicles in Illinois. Stroll through any Chicago parking lot or down the Kennedy Expressway during rush hour, and you’ll see a sea of neutral-colored cars. Just like white, these colors are everywhere, so naturally they appear often in ticket statistics. There’s nothing inherently “ticket-prone” about a gray Honda or a silver Toyota – they just happen to be very common.
It’s worth noting that no car color is immune to being pulled over. Whether you drive a blue car, a black SUV, or a green sedan, if you commit a traffic violation in Chicago, the police won’t ignore it because of your paint job. Some people wonder if darker cars, like black or navy blue, might get away with more at night, or if brighter colors like yellow might avoid tickets by being cheerful. The truth is, officers aren’t basing their decisions on hue. They may not even notice the color until after they’ve decided to initiate the stop. When a Chicago police officer radios in a traffic stop, they typically mention the car’s make, model, or license plate — color is secondary. All colors are equal in the eyes of the law; it’s driver behavior that makes the difference.
4. Driving Habits Matter More Than Color (Real Reasons for Chicago Traffic Stops)
If car color isn’t a major factor, what does cause Chicago drivers to get pulled over? The answer: how you drive. Police officers focus on driving behavior and violations, not the paint color on your vehicle. Here are the top reasons you’re likely to be stopped by Chicago police or Illinois state troopers:
- Speeding: This is the #1 cause of traffic stops and tickets. Exceeding the speed limit (especially by a wide margin) will get you noticed fast. In Illinois, speeding is taken seriously because it’s a leading cause of accidents. (Chicago even uses automated speed cameras near schools and parks — those cameras certainly don’t care what color your car is!)
- Aggressive or Reckless Driving: Behaviors like tailgating, weaving through lanes on the Dan Ryan Expressway, not using turn signals, or cutting off other cars will draw police attention. These unsafe moves stand out far more than the color of your vehicle.
- Running Red Lights or Stop Signs: In the city, running a red light is a quick way to get pulled over (or caught by a red-light camera). Chicago has many red-light cameras at busy intersections, and they ticket thousands of drivers regardless of car color.
- Distracted Driving: Texting or talking on a phone (without hands-free) is illegal in Illinois and very dangerous. If an officer sees you looking at your phone or otherwise not paying attention, you could be stopped.
- Equipment Violations: While less common as a primary reason, things like a broken headlight/taillight, expired license plates, or extremely loud exhaust can be reasons for a traffic stop. These issues can make your car stand out to the police more than the paint color does.
In short, Chicago police are watching for what you do, not what color your car is. This is backed up by data: for example, younger drivers (under 25) tend to get more tickets, not because of the color cars they drive, but because they’re more likely to speed or make risky choices. Likewise, a high-performance sports car might get more attention on the road, but it’s usually due to the driver pushing the limits. If you follow the traffic laws and drive courteously, you greatly reduce your chances of getting pulled over — no matter if your car is white, red, or purple.
5. Car Color vs. Insurance Rates in Illinois
Many drivers also wonder if the color of their car affects auto insurance rates. There’s a common misconception that owning a red car will make your insurance premiums higher (as if insurers think you’ll drive faster or be ticketed more). The good news is that Illinois insurance companies do not use car color as a factor in determining rates. Insurance providers care about your driving record, the vehicle’s make and model, its age, engine size, and how you use the car – not the paint color. Whether your car is fire-engine red or plain white has no direct impact on what you pay for insurance.
When you get an auto insurance quote in Chicago, you’ll notice they ask for your vehicle’s VIN, year, make, model, and maybe the mileage and usage (personal or business), but they never ask for color. A sporty red coupe might cost more to insure than a gray minivan, but that’s because of the type of car and the driver’s profile, not the color itself. Illinois insurance regulations ensure that rates are based on risk factors supported by data – and there’s no evidence that color alone makes someone a riskier driver.
That said, if you do get pulled over for a moving violation (in any color car) and receive a ticket, it can affect your insurance. Illinois drivers who accumulate speeding tickets or other violations may see their premiums rise upon renewal, because infractions suggest higher risk. So, while car color won’t change your insurance rate, your driving behavior certainly can. This is one more reason to focus on safe driving instead of worrying about paint jobs. And remember, Illinois law requires all drivers to carry insurance. If you’re driving in Chicago, make sure you at least have the state’s minimum liability coverage of 25/50/20 ($25,000 bodily injury per person, $50,000 per accident, and $20,000 property damage per accident). If you ever do get pulled over, you’ll need to show proof of insurance – and if you don’t have it, the color of your car will be the least of your worries!
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: Does car color affect insurance rates in Illinois?
A: No. Car insurance companies in Illinois do not consider the color of your car when setting your rate. Whether your car is red, white, or blue has no impact on your premium – insurers care far more about your driving record, claims history, and the type of vehicle you drive.
Q: What happens if I’m pulled over without insurance in Illinois?
A: Driving without insurance in Illinois can lead to serious penalties. If you’re pulled over in Chicago (or anywhere in the state) and can’t provide proof of at least the minimum required coverage, you’ll likely receive a costly ticket. Illinois law mandates minimum liability insurance (25/50/20 coverage), and being caught without it can result in fines up to $1,000 and a driver’s license suspension until you show proof of insurance. Always carry your insurance card to avoid these troubles.
Q: Are red cars more likely to get pulled over for speeding?
A: No, that’s largely a myth. Police don’t target vehicles based on color. Red cars have a reputation for getting more tickets, but in reality, white cars see the most stops simply because there are more of them on the road. Any car can get pulled over if the driver is speeding or breaking traffic laws – color doesn’t give you a free pass or extra scrutiny.
Q: What’s the minimum auto insurance coverage required in Illinois?
A: Illinois requires drivers to carry at least $25,000 in bodily injury liability per person and $50,000 per accident, as well as $20,000 in property damage liability. This is often written as “25/50/20” coverage. These are the state minimums to legally drive; you can choose higher limits for better protection. If you’re pulled over, an officer will expect you to have proof of at least this level of insurance.
Q: Will a speeding ticket increase my insurance rates in Illinois?
A: It can. Insurance companies in Illinois review your driving record at renewal time. One speeding ticket might be forgiven by some insurers, but it often leads to a higher rate, especially if it’s a major violation or if you have other tickets on your record. To keep your premiums low, drive safely and obey speed limits – regardless of your car’s color!
Get a Quote Today!
Chicago streets can be unpredictable, but your insurance doesn’t have to be. Insure on the Spot is a local expert in affordable auto coverage for Illinois drivers. Our team understands Chicago driving realities and myths alike (yes, even the red car myth!). We’re here to help you stay protected with the right policy. Call 773-202-5060 or get a Free Quote Online Today to see how we can save you money and keep you confidently covered on the road.