In Chicago, the types of cars that have the lowest insurance rates are often safe, modestly priced vehicles like compact SUVs and small pickup trucks. These car types combine high safety ratings with lower repair costs, which leads to cheaper insurance premiums. Local drivers can benefit from choosing such vehicles to keep their costs down.
Insure on the Spot offers Chicago drivers competitive rates on any car — call Insure on the Spot at 773-202-5060 today for an affordable quote.
Which Vehicles Have the Lowest Insurance Rates in Chicago, Illinois?
Chicago drivers looking to save on auto insurance should pay attention to the type of vehicle they drive. Generally, family-friendly and utilitarian vehicles tend to have the lowest insurance rates. Compact SUVs, midsize crossover vehicles, and even some small pickup trucks top the list for cheap insurance. These vehicles are designed with safety in mind and usually have moderate purchase prices, which both contribute to lower premiums. By contrast, high-end sports cars or luxury vehicles come with heftier insurance costs due to expensive parts and higher accident risks.
In Illinois and nationwide, insurance data shows that certain models consistently rank as the cheapest to insure. For example, popular compact SUVs like the Subaru Outback and Honda CR-V are known for their affordable premiums. Trucks such as the Toyota Tacoma also tend to be budget-friendly on insurance. Below is a quick look at some top car models known for low insurance rates and their categories:
| Vehicle Model | Category | Approx. Annual Premium (Full Coverage) |
| Subaru Outback | Compact SUV | ~$2,200 (national average) |
| Honda CR-V | Compact SUV | ~$2,250 (national average) |
| Toyota RAV4 | Compact SUV | ~$2,400 (national average) |
| Toyota Tacoma | Small Pickup Truck | ~$2,380 (national average) |
| Jeep Wrangler (Sport) | SUV (Off-Road) | ~$2,375 (national average) |
(Note: Premium estimates are for full coverage and can vary based on driver and location.)*
As shown above, compact SUVs and similar vehicles often come with lower insurance costs. Their combination of safety, reliability, and moderate repair costs makes them less risky in the eyes of insurers. For a Chicago driver, choosing one of these vehicle types can help keep insurance bills manageable. On the other hand, if you drive a high-performance sports car or an expensive luxury sedan on Chicago’s streets, expect to pay significantly more for insurance. The gap in premiums between a safe compact SUV and a sporty coupe can be thousands of dollars per year.
Why Safe, Affordable Cars Cost Less to Insure
Why do vehicles like SUVs and pickups generally have lower insurance rates? Insurance companies base premiums on risk, both the risk of the car being in an accident and the potential cost of claims if it is. Several key factors make a car cheaper to insure:
- High Safety Ratings: Cars with advanced safety features and top crash-test ratings (for example, those rated highly by the IIHS) are involved in fewer severe accidents. If you’re driving a vehicle known for protecting its occupants, like a Honda CR-V or Subaru Outback, insurers see a lower chance of costly injury claims. Safer cars help keep you protected on busy Chicago highways like the Dan Ryan, and they reward you with lower premiums.
- Lower Repair Costs: An affordable car with widely available, inexpensive parts will cost less to fix after an accident. A modest vehicle (say, a Toyota Camry or Ford Escape) is cheaper for insurance companies to repair than a luxury car with pricey components. Lower potential payout for repairs means a lower rate for you.
- Less Theft Risk: Some cars are simply stolen less often. Family vehicles and older models with good security aren’t prime targets for thieves, whereas certain popular models or high-end sports cars might be. In Chicago, where auto theft rates have been high in recent years, owning a car that’s not frequently targeted can keep your comprehensive insurance costs down.
- Moderate Performance: Cars built for everyday use (commuters, family vans, etc.) encourage safer driving habits. A minivan or crossover isn’t typically driven at high speeds like a sports coupe. Insurance companies recognize that moderate-performance vehicles are involved in fewer aggressive driving incidents. Essentially, a sensible car often equates to a sensible driver, translating into fewer claims.
All these factors mean that if you drive a safe, non-luxury vehicle, you’re likely to pay less for insurance. Illinois insurers take vehicle specifics into account: a robust airbag system, anti-lock brakes, or anti-theft devices can even earn you additional discounts. For Chicago residents, picking a car that scores well on these points is a smart way to push your premium down without sacrificing the coverage you need.
Chicago vs. Illinois: How Location Affects Your Insurance Costs
Your location in Illinois plays a big role in car insurance rates, and Chicago drivers know this well. Urban driving in Chicago comes with heavy traffic, dense population, and higher chances of accidents or claims. There’s also a greater risk of incidents like car theft or vandalism in the city. Chicago has experienced surges in vehicle thefts in recent years, reaching record highs, a factor that insurance companies cannot ignore. As a result, car insurance in Chicago tends to cost more than in smaller Illinois towns or rural areas.
For example, a driver in the heart of Chicago may pay considerably more for the same coverage than a driver in a quiet suburb or a rural area of Illinois. Higher traffic density on Chicago’s expressways means more frequent fender-benders and collisions. Likewise, urban areas often see more claims due to bumper-to-bumper commuting and tight parking situations. Insurers account for these risks by adjusting premiums upward in cities.
On the flip side, rural Illinois drivers or those in smaller cities like Peoria or Springfield often enjoy lower base rates. Fewer cars on the road means a lower chance of accidents. Lower population density also correlates with fewer insurance claims overall. Plus, if you live outside the city, you might drive more on open highways and less in start-and-stop congestion, which can reduce accident risk.
It’s important to note that even within Illinois, insurance is highly personalized. If you’re a Chicago resident, you can still keep costs down by driving a low-risk vehicle (like the ones discussed above) and maintaining a clean driving record. Conversely, a rural Illinois driver with a poor record or a flashy sports car could still face high premiums despite their location. In every case, combining a safe car choice with safe driving habits is the winning formula.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: What’s the minimum auto insurance required in Illinois?
A: Illinois law requires at least 25/50/20 liability coverage. That means you need $25,000 for bodily injury per person, $50,000 per accident for bodily injury to others, and $20,000 for property damage. These are the state minimums to drive legally, though many drivers in Chicago opt for higher limits or additional coverage for better protection.
Q: Are car insurance rates higher in Chicago than in other parts of Illinois?
A: Yes. Chicago tends to have higher car insurance rates than the rest of Illinois. Urban factors like heavy traffic, more accidents, and high car theft rates push premiums up in the city. A Chicago driver might pay several hundred dollars more per year on average than someone in a smaller Illinois city with a similar profile.
Q: Does the type of car I drive affect my insurance premium in Illinois?
A: Absolutely. Insurance companies in Illinois heavily factor in your vehicle’s make and model. Safe, moderately priced cars (like family SUVs or sedans with good safety records) generally cost less to insure. If you drive a high-performance sports car or an expensive luxury vehicle, expect higher premiums because those cars are involved in more claims and cost more to repair.
Q: How can I lower my car insurance costs in Chicago?
A: To save on car insurance in Chicago, start by choosing a vehicle that’s cheap to insure – one with solid safety ratings and low theft rates. Also, maintain a clean driving record and a good credit score, as both can earn you discounts.
Get a Quote Today!
Insure on the Spot is Chicago’s local expert in affordable auto coverage. Our team understands Illinois insurance inside and out – from city traffic challenges to state coverage requirements. Whether you drive a compact SUV, a sedan, or a pickup truck, we can help find you the lowest insurance rate for your vehicle.
Get started with confidence – call 773-202-5060 or visit our website for a Free Quote Online Today! and see how much you can save!