CALL NOW 773-202-5060 | Español
  • Make My Payment
  • Renew My Policy
  • Customer Service
  • Locations
  • Contact Us
Insure On The Spot
  • Auto Insurance
  • SR22 Insurance
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Get Free Quote
  • Make My Payment
  • Renew My Policy
  • Customer Service
    • Payment Options
    • Roadside Assistance
    • Report An Auto Insurance Claim
    • Auto Insurance FAQs
    • Tips & Resources (Articles)
  • Locations
    • Corporate Headquarters
    • Chicago, IL South
    • Berwyn, IL
    • Melrose Park, IL
  • Contact Us
‹ back to All Auto Insurance Tips
Dec
4

How to Find a Collision Repair Shop After an Accident in Chicago

UPDATED: October 8, 2025
Share:

In the aftermath of a car accident in Chicago, you need to quickly find a collision repair shop you can trust to restore your vehicle properly. Insure on the Spot is here to help local drivers navigate the process confidently from the insurance claim to choosing the right shop.

Call Insure on the Spot in Chicago at 773-202-5060 for immediate assistance after an accident and guidance with your claim. This guide outlines the essential steps to secure quality repairs and get back on the road safely.

1. Ensure Safety First and Document the Accident

Your priority after any accident is safety. Check for injuries and move to a safe area out of traffic if possible. In Chicago’s busy streets, turning on your hazard lights and getting to the shoulder or a side street can prevent further incidents. Once everyone is safe, call 911 to report the accident and request police assistance if needed (especially for significant damage or injuries). A police report creates an official record, which is very helpful when dealing with insurance.

Exchange information with the other driver calmly and thoroughly. Gather their name, contact number, insurance company and policy number, driver’s license number, and license plate. It’s also wise to note the make and model of the other car and the exact location of the crash (intersection or landmark). Use your phone to take photos of the damage, the scene, and the other vehicle’s license plate. Detailed documentation will support your insurance claim and help the collision repair shop understand the damage.

Key immediate steps to remember:

  • Call 911: Report any injuries and get a police report if possible.
  • Move to safety: If drivable, pull over to avoid blocking Chicago traffic.
  • Exchange details: Swap insurance info, contact numbers, and driver’s license info.
  • Document the scene: Take photos of all damage, street signs, and any relevant road conditions.

Staying calm and collected during these first steps will make the rest of the repair and claims process much smoother.

2. File an Insurance Claim and Notify Your Insurer

After ensuring everyone’s safety, contact your auto insurance company as soon as you can to report the accident. Prompt reporting is crucial – it triggers the claims process and helps you get guidance on next steps. If you’re insured with Insure on the Spot, our Chicago-based agents can walk you through filing the claim right over the phone. Be ready to provide the details you gathered: when and where the accident happened, a description of what occurred, and the other driver’s information. Quick notification helps avoid delays and gets your claim moving forward without hassle.

Illinois is an “at-fault” state, meaning the driver who caused the accident (or their insurance) is generally responsible for covering damages. If another driver was at fault, their insurance might try to direct you to specific repair shops. Remember, you are not obligated to use a shop just because an insurance company recommends it. Whether the claim is through your insurer or the other party’s, you have the right to choose who fixes your car. Your insurance company may suggest trusted Chicago-area body shops (and even help arrange towing), but the final decision is yours. While on the call, ask about your policy’s coverage: for example, confirm if you have rental car coverage to use while your car is in the shop.

When filing your claim, keep these tips in mind:

  1. Have your info ready: Provide date, time, location of the accident, and police report number if you have one.
  2. Be honest and accurate: Describe what happened without admitting fault; let the investigation determine liability.
  3. Ask about coverage: Find out your deductible, what repairs are covered, and if a rental car is covered during repairs.
  4. Note the claim number: Write down your claim reference number and your adjuster’s contact information for easy follow-up.

By promptly involving your insurer, you’ll get professional guidance on assessments and next steps, making the journey to a repaired vehicle much smoother.

3. Choose a Reputable Chicago Collision Repair Shop

One of the most important decisions after an accident is selecting the collision repair shop that will fix your vehicle. Chicago has many auto body shops, but they’re not all equal. Take time to research and choose a reputable shop that meets your needs. You’re entitled to pick the repair facility you trust, whether or not it’s in an insurance company’s suggested network. A quality repair shop will ensure your car is restored to safe driving condition and preserve its value.

Start by asking for recommendations from people you trust. Friends, family, or coworkers in Chicago may have had positive experiences with local body shops. Additionally, check online reviews on Google or Yelp for shops in your neighborhood. Consistently high ratings and customer feedback about workmanship and service are good signs. It’s also wise to look for industry certifications that signal a shop’s quality. Certifications like I-CAR Gold Class (indicating advanced training) or ASE-certified technicians show that the staff is properly trained in collision repair. Some shops are even certified by specific car manufacturers, meaning they meet the standards to work on those brands.

Consider the following factors when evaluating collision repair shops:

FactorWhat to Look For
Experience & ReputationLong-standing shops with a strong reputation in Chicago’s community. Longevity can mean trustworthiness.
CertificationsI-CAR Gold Class or ASE-certified technicians, indicating advanced training and skill.
Warranty on RepairsShops that offer a warranty (lifetime or multi-year) on their repair work, giving you peace of mind.
OEM vs. Aftermarket PartsAsk if they use original manufacturer (OEM) parts. OEM parts can fit better and last longer, though quality aftermarket parts can save cost.
Insurance AssistanceShops that work smoothly with insurance companies, handle claim paperwork, and have experience with the claims process.
Customer ServiceFriendly, clear communication. They should explain the repairs needed and keep you updated on progress.

Visiting the shop (or its website) can also give you a feel for their professionalism. A clean, well-organized facility with modern equipment is a positive sign that they take their work seriously. Ultimately, choose a collision repair shop that makes you feel confident about leaving your car in their hands. Remember, this is your vehicle and your investment – you have every right to decide who repairs it.

4. Get Estimates and Ask the Right Questions

Before authorizing any work, it’s smart to obtain a repair estimate (or even a few estimates from different shops). In a city the size of Chicago, you have plenty of choices, so comparing quotes can help ensure you’re getting a fair deal. When you bring your car in for an estimate, the technicians will inspect the damage – sometimes both external and underlying damage – and provide a written estimate of what the repairs will entail and how much they’ll cost. Share a copy of this estimate with your insurance adjuster, especially if there are differences between the shop’s estimate and the insurance company’s initial assessment. In many cases, the adjuster and the shop will communicate to agree on repair costs.

Don’t hesitate to ask questions about the estimate and repair process. Clear communication is a hallmark of a good repair shop. Here are some key questions to ask when reviewing an estimate with the shop manager or technician:

  • What is included in this estimate? Ensure it covers parts, labor, paint, and any additional fees. Will they also address hidden damage if found (with insurance approval)?
  • Are you using OEM or aftermarket parts? If you prefer original parts, let them know. Some insurers specify aftermarket to save cost, but you might opt to pay the difference for OEM.
  • How long will the repairs take? Get an estimate of the repair timeline. Chicago’s busy shops might have wait times; also, ask if they will notify you of any delays.
  • Do you offer a warranty on the repairs? Reputable shops usually guarantee their work. Know how long the warranty lasts and what it covers (e.g., paint, parts, labor).
  • Can you help with a rental car? If you need alternate transportation, see if the shop coordinates with rental services or if your insurance rental coverage will be handled seamlessly.

By comparing estimates and asking these questions, you’ll feel confident about the shop you choose and avoid surprises down the road. Make sure you are comfortable with the shop’s answers before giving the green light. Once you authorize a repair, the shop will begin work, and your insurance company will typically pay the shop directly (minus any deductible you owe). Keep in touch with the repair shop during the process; good communication ensures you know how the repairs are progressing.

5. Inspect the Repairs and Wrap Up the Claim

When your car’s repairs are complete, don’t rush just to drive away – take time to inspect the work thoroughly. Reputable Chicago collision repair shops will gladly walk you through the repairs they performed. Carefully look over your vehicle in good lighting. The paint should match the rest of the car’s color and finish with no obvious differences. Check that body panels line up evenly and there are no noticeable gaps – a well-done repair will make the car look and feel just as it did before the accident.

It’s also important to ensure all mechanical and safety features are back in working order. Test the headlights, brake lights, turn signals, and any new parts that were installed. If your car has sensors or cameras (common in newer vehicles for parking or collision avoidance), make sure they’re functioning properly. On your first drive after repairs, pay attention to how the car feels – the steering should be aligned, and there should be no unexpected noises, vibrations, or warning lights on the dashboard. Chicago’s potholes and rough roads can knock things out of alignment, so a quality repair should include an alignment check if the impact was significant.

Before you officially close the claim, address any concerns with the repair shop. If you spot an issue, like a power window not working or a slight paint imperfection, let the shop know right away. Good shops will fix any lingering problems as part of their service, especially if they offer a warranty. Only when you are satisfied should you sign off on the repairs.

Finally, consider the insurance aspect moving forward. If you were at fault in the accident, be aware that your insurance premiums might change at your next renewal (many Illinois insurers impose a surcharge after an at-fault accident). If you were not at fault, this claim likely won’t raise your rates – but it’s always wise to discuss with your agent. Either way, completing the repairs properly and having your car back in shape is a big relief. With a trusted insurance partner and a quality repair shop, you’ve successfully navigated a stressful situation and can drive with confidence again.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)


Q: Do I have to use the repair shop my insurance company recommends?

A: No. In Illinois, you have the right to choose your collision repair shop. Insurance companies may suggest preferred shops in their network, but the final decision is yours. Pick a shop you trust for quality repairs, even if it’s not the one your insurer suggests.


Q: Will filing a collision claim raise my insurance rates in Chicago?

A: If you caused the accident, a claim can lead to higher premiums at renewal (some insurers offer accident forgiveness for your first at-fault crash). If you were not at fault, your rates typically won’t increase due to that claim. Every insurance company is different, so discuss concerns with your agent to know what to expect.


Q: Do I need a police report for an insurance claim in Chicago?

A: It’s highly recommended. A police report provides official documentation of the accident, which helps the claims process. In Chicago, you can call the police to the scene for any significant accident. While minor fender-benders without injuries might not legally require a report, having one will make your insurance claim smoother and more credible.


Q: What’s the minimum auto insurance required in Illinois?

A: Illinois drivers must carry at least 25/50/20 liability coverage. That means $25,000 bodily injury coverage per person, $50,000 per accident, and $20,000 for property damage. These are just the legal minimums – many Chicago drivers opt for higher coverage limits or additional protections (like collision and comprehensive) to stay better protected on the road.


Get a Quote Today!

Accidents are stressful, but having a reliable local insurance partner makes all the difference. Insure on the Spot is Chicago’s trusted auto insurance expert with deep local expertise. We’ve helped drivers through every step of accidents and repairs. Call 773-202-5060 or get a Free Quote Online Today to experience the peace of mind we provide on Chicago’s roads.

 

In: Claims
‹ back to All Auto Insurance Tips

Get Auto Insurance

Choose a Topic:

  • Affordability
  • Claims
  • Coverages
  • Driving Local: Chicago Guide
  • Education
  • International
  • Legal
  • License & Registration
  • Maintenance
  • Rentals
  • Safety
  • SR-22
  • Tips
  • Uncategorized
  • Vehicle Type Guides
Road Curve
Services
  • Auto Insurance
  • SR22 Insurance
  • Motorcycle Insurance
  • Get FREE Quote
  • Make My Payment
  • Renew My Policy
  • Call Now 1-773-202-5060
Locations
  • Corporate Headquarters
  • Chicago, IL South
  • Berwyn, IL
  • Melrose Park, IL
  • Additional Areas Served
Need Help?
  • Easy Payment Options
  • Report a Claim
  • Auto Insurance FAQs
  • Tips & Resources (Articles)
  • Contact Us
  • Employment Opportunities
  • Location Finder
  • ILIVS Illinois Insurance Verification System
  • See what our customers are saying about us!
Get Auto Insurance
Get Free Quote
  • Affiliate Login
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
  • Terms & Conditions
Copyright © 2026 Insure On The Spot
Trusted Since 1986